Today on "Trope Theater", we explore a vastly underrated and underused monster phenotype known as
Vegetibilis Man-Eaterus or the Man-Eating Plant.
Horror's fascination with the MEP began with the South Australian Register in 1881. They printed an account from 1878 by a certain Dr. Carl Liche that described a man-eating tree's attack of a young woman of the Mkodos tribe in Madagascar. Seeing as how Dr. Liche, the Mkodos tribe and the tree appear never to have existed, the story has since been assumed to be utter and complete bullshit.
Since then, however, the MEP has dominated our collective imaginations. Most often appearing in literature, authors from Sir Arthur Conan Doyle to J.R.R. Tolkein to modern scribes such as Annie Proulx have given us some truly terrifying botanical monstrosities. Films such as Day of the Triffids, Jumanji, Dinner for Adele, The Lost World, and MY absolute favorite, Little Shop of Horrors have inspired many a child to eat their Brussels sprouts before the sprouts eat them.
Really, Phantom? Seriously?
But why do they freak us out?
Well, the common assumption is that we don't want to get eaten. There is that piece of our brain that still says "Things should not be chewing on my face. It just ain't right." There's more to it, though.
You'll notice that the newspaper account given above was printed shortly after Darwin's book
Insectivorous Plants was published in 1875. Given that, it's only logical that someone with a fairly imaginative brain would come up with a plant that would mindlessly snag humans as a tea-time finger sandwich. (TEEHEE! Finger.) Given that Darwin's works at the time were being heavily debated, people were afraid that such a thing might actually exist and most people wouldn't take into account such things as "reality" and "the laws of biology and physics". We still have people today that believe in plant-like cryptids.
You don't want to know what's on that spoon.
And it's the mindless part that gets most people, seeing as how that's the most common depiction. The plant isn't thinking anything when it gets you. It just gets you through a series of automatic triggers.
The other part that gives folks the wiggins? Plants don't normally crunch you up. The MEP is the master of the lingering death. On the other hand, the Venus Flytrap, with its tooth-like fringe, has given a lot of folks artistic license to impart plants with the ability to chew (messily... it appears that not having hands kind of forces a lack of manners). Of course, that same artistic license allows these plants to sing, too, so... yeah.
Don't sing with your mouth full!
In any case, Man-Eating plants, as much as they wrap their grabby tendrils around our fear centers and tug, are most often used as a sight gag or as a minor enemy that just happens to block our protagonists' path. It's rare in film that we get an MEP big bad. When we DO get them, though... WHOOOOO boy.
In Little Shop of Horrors, not only do we get a Man-Eating Plant, but we get a classic Faustian bargain as well. Audrey II (or Audrey Jr. in the original Roger Corman classic) offers poor Seymour a life of fame, riches and the girl of his dreams if he just makes sure that the plant is fed regularly. In 2008, though, we got treated to some NASTY greenery in The Ruins. The vines in this temple have caused the locals to salt the earth around it so it can't spread. They don't just grab you. They INFILTRATE you. Much like certain tropical parasites, you have to cut them out. And they whisper to you. In that "edge of hearing" sort of way that makes you wonder if you're going mad.
I can understand why this trope doesn't get used often, though. MEPs are hard to use in film without them looking hokey. There's only so far foam and plastic leaves will take our minds. CGI helps but we, as the audience, have to be completely willing to suspend disbelief. The tiniest hint of reality will shatter this particular illusion.
But, if you'll excuse me, I have to go invest in some Round-Up. Yes, I know it's January. I don't care.